🤖DALL-E 3 已经上线超过一年,自从开放 API 和 GPT Plus 用户后一直备受关注。那么它真的值得大家的期待吗?
最好的方式当然是和另一款知名 AI 绘画工具 MidJourney 做个对比!
本文将带你了解 DALL-E 3 和 MidJourney 的基本情况,并通过不同场景下的图片质量和创意对比,帮你选择最适合自己的 AI 绘画工具。
🎨什么是 DALL-E 3?
DALL-E 是 OpenAI 推出的文本生成图片 AI 模型。你只需输入描述,无论是写实还是奇幻风格,它都能帮你生成图片,并能巧妙融合各种概念、属性和风格。
目前公开的最新版本是 DALL-E 3,画质和分辨率大幅提升,对复杂文本的理解也更准确。
🖼️什么是 MidJourney?
MidJourney同样可以根据文本描述生成高质量图片,是目前最受欢迎的 AI 绘画工具之一,画面真实感极强。
国内用户只能通过翻墙后使用Discord聊天机器人,MJ官网,或无墨使用。
⚖️Dall-E 3 vs MidJourney:评测标准
我们针对 7 个风格类别,分别用同样的英文 prompt 让 Dall-E 3 和 MidJourney 生成图片:
- 写实风格(Photorealism)
- 卡通风格(Cartoon)
- 抽象风格(Abstract)
- 像素画(Pixel art)
- 复古风格(Vintage)
- 手绘风格(Hand-drawn)
- 3D 渲染(3D Rendering)
每组图片我们都从 准确性、画质、创意 三方面进行对比。
—— 开始对比!——
🏆Dall-E 3 vs MidJourney:终极对比
Test 1: Photorealism 写实风格
Prompt: Generate a photo of a woman with a composed and thoughtful expression. She has shoulder-length wavy hair and is dressed in a sophisticated black turtleneck sweater paired with a charcoal grey pencil skirt. Her stance is poised, with her arms crossed lightly in front of her. The background is a blurred urban cityscape at dusk, with the warm glow of streetlights and the deep blue of the evening sky.


- MidJourney 的光影更自然,皮肤细节和表情更真实,整体更接近真实照片。
🥇MidJourney 胜出!
Test 2: Cartoon 卡通风格
Prompt: Generate a vibrant, cartoon-style image of a friendly robot in a bustling city park. The robot has a rounded body with a glossy, metallic finish, and it’s waving at a group of diverse cartoon animals gathered around it. The park is lively and colorful, with trees sporting exaggerated, rounded leaves and flowers with large, expressive eyes. The sky is a bright cerulean blue with puffy, white clouds.


- Dall-E 3 对 prompt 理解更好,色彩更鲜艳,细节丰富,甚至还加了直升机等额外元素。
🏅Dall-E 3 胜出!
Test 3: Abstractionism 抽象风格
Prompt: Generate an abstract image that captures the essence of a bustling cityscape. The image should use a vivid array of geometric shapes and a dynamic composition to represent the urban environment. Sharp angles and overlapping forms suggest skyscrapers and crowded streets, while a mix of bold and subdued colors convey the city’s energy and rhythm. The overall effect should be one of harmonious chaos, typical of abstractionism, inviting the viewer to interpret the scene through their own perspective


- 两者都很好地还原了抽象主义风格,表现力各有千秋。
🤝平分秋色!
Test 4: Pixel-art 像素画
Prompt: Generate a pixel art style image of a quaint village with small houses, a winding river, and a pixelated forest backdrop. The colors should be vibrant yet reminiscent of classic 16-bit video games.


- Dall-E 3 的像素感更强,画面更接近经典 16-bit 游戏风格。
🕹️Dall-E 3 胜出!
Test 5: Vintage 复古风格
Prompt: Create an image in the style of an early 20th-century sepia-toned photograph. The scene is a softly-focused still life on a wooden table, featuring an arrangement of vintage objects: an open, leather-bound book, a quill pen, a brass candlestick with a flickering candle, and a globe.


- MidJourney 的光影和色调更接近真实老照片,Dall-E 3 更有艺术感。
📷MidJourney 胜出!
Test 6: Hand-drawn 手绘风格
Prompt: Create an image in the style of a hand-drawn pencil sketch on textured paper. The drawing should feature a single person in early 1900s attire, standing in a relaxed pose, with a simplified background that suggests an old European street with minimal details.


- Dall-E 3 的线条和阴影更细腻,手绘感更强。
✏️Dall-E 3 胜出!
Test 7: 3D Renders 3D 渲染
Prompt: Generate a 3D image of a small, verdant floating island with surreal, colorful flora and a waterfall that turns into mist mid-air. The backdrop is a sunset sky with distant mountains and iridescent birds in flight


- Dall-E 3 对 prompt 理解更精准,细节还原度高。
🌈Dall-E 3 胜出!
最终结果:Dall-E 3 以 5:3 获胜
🎉无论是 Dall-E 3 还是 MidJourney,都能在多种风格下生成令人惊艳的图片。
写实风格上,MidJourney 更接近真实;但 Dall-E 3 在还原复杂描述和细节上表现更好。
其实没有绝对的优劣,选择最适合你创作风格和需求的工具才是王道!